UK Court Blocks Chagossians' Right of Return Bid
The UK Court of Appeal has refused to hear a last-ditch legal challenge by Chagossians living in Britain seeking the right to return to their homeland.
The UK Court of Appeal has refused to consider a fresh legal challenge brought by Chagossian islanders living in Britain, dealing another blow to those fighting for the right to return to the Chagos Islands, also known as the British Indian Ocean Territory (BIOT).
The case was rejected by Lady Justice Andrews, who ruled that the courts could not intervene in what she characterised as a political and diplomatic process. The applicants had based their challenge on two key arguments: the evolving circumstances surrounding the Chagos Islands and a landmark sovereignty agreement between the United Kingdom and Mauritius.
The Chagos Islands were separated from Mauritius by Britain in 1965, three years before Mauritius gained independence, in a move widely condemned as illegal under international law. The original Chagossian population was forcibly removed between 1967 and 1973 to make way for a major US military base on Diego Garcia, the largest island in the archipelago. Many were resettled in Mauritius and the Seychelles, while others later migrated to the United Kingdom, particularly to Crawley in West Sussex.
Decades of legal battles have followed. Chagossians have repeatedly challenged the British government in domestic and international courts, with mixed results. Some rulings have supported their right of return in principle, but no court has yet compelled the UK government to actually allow resettlement.
The latest case drew on the agreement in principle reached between London and Port Louis, under which the United Kingdom was set to recognise Mauritian sovereignty over the Chagos Islands in exchange for a long-term lease allowing the Diego Garcia base to continue operating. That deal, negotiated under the previous UK government and initially paused after a change of administration, has remained politically contested. Chagossian groups argued that this diplomatic shift and changed circumstances should allow the courts to revisit earlier rulings blocking their return.
Lady Justice Andrews disagreed, holding that the matter remained outside the scope of judicial intervention.
What this means: For the thousands of Chagossians living in the UK, this ruling closes off another legal avenue in a decades-long campaign. It reinforces that their right of return will ultimately depend on political decisions made in London and Port Louis, not court orders. The outcome of the Mauritius-UK sovereignty agreement, still unresolved, will likely be more decisive for the future of the islands than any further litigation in British courts. Chagossian advocates have consistently argued that any deal must include concrete guarantees of their right to resettle, something neither government has formally committed to in enforceable terms.
Source: Le Defi Media
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Chagossians' right of return?β
The right of return refers to the legal and moral claim of the Chagossian people to resettle the Chagos Islands, from which they were forcibly expelled by Britain between 1967 and 1973. The islands, located in the Indian Ocean roughly 1,500 km from Mauritius, are home to the Diego Garcia US military base. Despite various court rulings in their favour over the years, no British government has permitted permanent resettlement.
How does the Mauritius-UK Chagos deal affect Chagossians?β
An agreement in principle was reached between Mauritius and the United Kingdom under which the UK would recognise Mauritian sovereignty over the Chagos Islands while retaining a long-term lease for the Diego Garcia military base. Chagossian groups have argued that any such deal must include guaranteed resettlement rights, but neither government has formally committed to this. The deal remains politically unresolved as of 2025.
Where do most Chagossians live today?β
The Chagossian diaspora is spread across Mauritius, the Seychelles and the United Kingdom. In Britain, the largest community is concentrated in Crawley, West Sussex. Smaller communities also live in other parts of southern England. Estimates suggest several thousand Chagossians and their descendants now hold UK residency or citizenship.
From Our Network
Find Property in Mauritius
Search Listings β
π§ Breaking alerts straight to your inbox
