Chagos Sovereignty Is Law, Not British Favour
Mauritian constitutional lawyer Parvèz Dookhy says Nigel Farage's comments on the Chagos Islands are pure populism and ignore settled international law.
Mauritian constitutional lawyer Me Parvèz Dookhy has pushed back firmly against recent statements by British politician Nigel Farage on the Chagos Islands, calling them populist and legally uninformed.
Farage, leader of the UK Reform Party, has repeatedly argued that Britain should not hand over the Chagos archipelago to Mauritius, framing any such transfer as a political concession. Dookhy rejects that framing entirely.
"Sovereignty does not proceed from the generosity of the former colonial power," Dookhy said, in remarks reported by Le Defi Media. He argues that Mauritius's claim to the Chagos Islands rests on a solid foundation of international law, not on goodwill from London.
The Chagos Islands, officially known as the British Indian Ocean Territory, were separated from Mauritius by Britain in 1965, three years before Mauritian independence, as a condition of that independence. Mauritius has long argued that this separation was illegal under international law, which prohibits the dismemberment of a colony before independence.
That position received major legal backing in 2019, when the International Court of Justice, the principal judicial body of the United Nations, issued an advisory opinion stating that Britain's continued administration of the Chagos Islands was unlawful and that the decolonisation of Mauritius had never been lawfully completed. The UN General Assembly subsequently passed a resolution calling on the UK to end its administration of the territory.
In 2024, the UK and Mauritius reached a landmark agreement in principle under which Britain would formally cede sovereignty of the Chagos Islands to Mauritius, while retaining use of Diego Garcia, the strategically important military base operated jointly with the United States. That deal has since faced political headwinds in the UK, with figures like Farage leading opposition to it.
Dookhy's point is that the legal foundation for Mauritian sovereignty was established long before any negotiated deal. The ICJ opinion, the UN resolution, and decades of international consensus all support Mauritius's position, he argues. For him, Farage's framing misrepresents the legal reality by suggesting that the UK has a free choice about whether to recognise Mauritius's rights.
The lawyer's remarks echo those of Chagossian activist Olivier Bancoult, who also recently said that Farage does not understand the detail of the Chagos file.
What this means: For Mauritius, the distinction matters politically and legally. If sovereignty is a matter of right under international law, then any UK government that delays or reverses the agreement is acting against binding international norms, not simply exercising a domestic policy choice. This strengthens Mauritius's hand in future negotiations and in any potential legal challenge.
Source: Le Defi Media
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the International Court of Justice say about the Chagos Islands?−
In 2019, the ICJ issued an advisory opinion concluding that Britain's separation of the Chagos Islands from Mauritius in 1965 was unlawful and that the decolonisation of Mauritius had not been legitimately completed. The UN General Assembly passed a resolution calling on the UK to end its administration of the territory.
What is the current status of the Chagos Islands deal between the UK and Mauritius?−
In 2024, the UK and Mauritius reached an agreement in principle to transfer sovereignty of the Chagos Islands to Mauritius. Under the deal, the UK and US would retain use of the Diego Garcia military base. The agreement has faced political opposition in the UK, particularly from Nigel Farage's Reform Party.
Who is Me Parvèz Dookhy?−
Me Parvèz Dookhy is a Mauritian constitutional lawyer who has been a prominent commentator on the Chagos Islands dispute. He argues that Mauritius's sovereignty over the archipelago is grounded in international law, specifically the 2019 ICJ advisory opinion and subsequent UN resolutions.
From Our Network
Find Property in Mauritius
Search Listings →
📧 Breaking alerts straight to your inbox
