Mauritius Press Freedom Debate: Go After Fake Profiles, Not Journalists
Panellists on ION News say police should target fake accounts spreading smears online rather than summoning independent media outlets.
Press freedom in Mauritius came under sharp scrutiny during a recent episode of L'Heure du Débat, a current-affairs debate programme on ION News, with panellists arguing that authorities are directing their attention at the wrong targets.
The discussion was triggered by a wave of police summonses sent to several online media outlets in recent months. Those summonses followed coverage of social unrest linked to the cost-of-living crisis, the ongoing water-supply shortages affecting many parts of the island, and high-profile cases involving alleged drug kingpins.
Samad Golamaully, one of the panellists, was blunt in his criticism. Speaking in Mauritian Creole, he argued that every government that has come to power in Mauritius has tried to rein in the press, tolerating coverage only when it is flattering. He insisted that an independent press is as essential to democracy as an independent Supreme Court, and that journalists should be free to report facts and express informed opinion without fear of reprisal.
Golamaully reserved particular criticism for the use of anonymous social-media accounts. He pointed out that much of the most damaging online content does not come from registered media organisations but from fake profiles designed to defame individuals. His message to the police was direct: instead of calling journalists in for questioning, investigators should be tracking down and prosecuting those who hide behind false identities to destroy people's reputations.
Lawyer Arassen Kallee drew a comparison with India, noting that in that country the press is broadly respected and that the real problem lies not in the articles journalists publish but in the anonymous comment sections that follow them. He raised the question of moral responsibility, suggesting that platforms and readers alike need to think more carefully about what they share and amplify.
The debate touched on a tension that has grown more visible in Mauritius in recent years. Online media outlets have multiplied rapidly, giving citizens faster access to news that traditional broadcasters sometimes hesitate to publish. At the same time, the legal framework governing digital journalism remains patchy, leaving outlets and their editors exposed to broad investigative powers that critics say can be used to intimidate rather than to uphold the law.
What this means: For readers, journalists and anyone who follows Mauritian public life online, the core issue is accountability on two fronts. Registered news outlets argue they should be treated the same way as the established press, with the protections that come with that status. At the same time, the debate highlights a gap in enforcement: anonymous accounts that spread misinformation or defamation rarely face the same scrutiny that identifiable journalists do. Until that imbalance is addressed, critics say, press-freedom concerns in Mauritius will keep growing.
Source: ION News
Frequently Asked Questions
Why have online media outlets in Mauritius been summoned by police?−
Several Mauritian online news outlets received police summonses following their coverage of social unrest over the cost-of-living crisis, water-supply failures affecting communities across the island, and cases linked to alleged drug traffickers. Critics argue the summonses amount to pressure on independent journalism rather than legitimate legal proceedings.
What is L'Heure du Débat on ION News?−
L'Heure du Débat is a current-affairs debate programme broadcast on ION News, one of Mauritius's online news platforms. It regularly features lawyers, journalists, politicians and civil-society figures discussing topical issues in Mauritian Creole and French.
Is using a fake profile to defame someone illegal in Mauritius?−
Mauritius has provisions under the Information and Communication Technologies Act and the Criminal Code that can apply to online defamation and identity misuse. However, enforcement against anonymous fake accounts has been limited, which is precisely what panellists on the ION News debate criticised, calling on police to pursue those accounts rather than summoning identifiable media outlets.
From Our Network
Find Property in Mauritius
Search Listings →
📧 Breaking alerts straight to your inbox
