FCC Overstepped by Blocking Lee Shim's Chosen Lawyer, Affidavit Says
A legal affidavit argues the Financial Crimes Commission violated Mauritius's constitution by telling a suspect which lawyer he could not use.
A legal dispute unfolding in Mauritius is raising a fundamental question about the rights of anyone questioned by an anti-corruption body: can an investigating authority tell a suspect which lawyer they are not allowed to have?
An affidavit filed in what observers are calling the FCC Lee Shim case argues firmly that the answer is no, and that the Financial Crimes Commission went far beyond its legal powers when it did exactly that.
The Financial Crimes Commission, known as the FCC, is Mauritius's dedicated agency for investigating financial crime and corruption. It was set up under its own legislation and operates independently of the police, with broad powers to summon, question and investigate individuals suspected of financial offences.
At the heart of this dispute is what happened when attorney Shamir Hossany attended an FCC interview to represent his client. According to the affidavit, FCC officials informed Hossany that he was in a conflict of interest and would not be permitted to act for the person being questioned. The affidavit challenges that decision as unlawful.
The legal argument rests on the Mauritian Constitution. Section 10(2)(d) guarantees any person facing a criminal charge the right to be represented by a legal representative of their own choice. Section 5(3) extends a similar protection to anyone who is arrested or detained. Section 10(2)(c) covers the right to have adequate time and facilities to prepare a defence. Together, these provisions make the free choice of lawyer not a procedural luxury but a constitutional guarantee.
The affidavit goes further by arguing that this protection cannot be switched on only once formal charges are filed. It must apply from the investigation stage, because it is during questioning, before any charge is laid, that the foundation of a future prosecution is built. What a person says or does not say at that early point can shape everything that follows.
Critically, the affidavit challenges who has the authority to decide whether a lawyer has a conflict of interest. Under the legal and ethical rules that govern the Mauritian legal profession, that determination belongs to the Bar Council, to a court, or to the lawyer themselves, all of whom are bound by professional conduct rules. It does not belong to the body conducting the investigation. Allowing an accuser to choose or exclude the accused's legal representative would, the document argues, fundamentally undermine the independence of the defence.
What this means: if the court agrees with the affidavit, the FCC's handling of this interview could be found unconstitutional, with potential consequences for any evidence or admissions gathered during it. More broadly, the case could force the FCC and similar bodies to clarify the limits of their authority when dealing with legal representation. For anyone called in for questioning by a Mauritian investigative authority, the outcome of this case could directly affect what rights they can count on from the moment they walk into that room.
The case is continuing and no final ruling has been reported at this stage.
Source: ION News
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Financial Crimes Commission (FCC) in Mauritius?β
The Financial Crimes Commission is a Mauritian independent body established to investigate financial crimes, corruption and money laundering. It has powers to summon and question individuals and operates separately from the Mauritius Police Force.
Does the Mauritian Constitution guarantee the right to choose your own lawyer?β
Yes. Section 10(2)(d) of the Mauritian Constitution guarantees the right to legal representation of one's own choice for anyone charged with a criminal offence. Section 5(3) provides a similar protection for anyone who is arrested or detained.
Can an investigating authority in Mauritius decide that your lawyer has a conflict of interest?β
The affidavit in the FCC Lee Shim case argues they cannot. Under Mauritian law, questions of conflict of interest concerning a lawyer fall under the jurisdiction of the Bar Council or the courts, not the body conducting the investigation.
From Our Network
Find Property in Mauritius
Search Listings β
π§ Breaking alerts straight to your inbox
